← Back to Interviews
November 20, 2026·VIDEO
For The Love of Truth cover art

For The Love of Truth

with Adrian Gregory

What Happens When We Die? Brendan Murphy on Consciousness & Reincarnation

Brendan joins Adrian Gregory on For The Love of Truth to ask what happens when we die. He explains why near-death experiences look so different from culture to culture while following the same underlying structure, and why the brain behaves less like a producer of consciousness and more like a filter that narrows it.

They look at Eben Alexander's near-death experience beside Rudolf Steiner's account of the Devachan realm, Ian Stevenson's reincarnation research with children, and why Brendan takes the "soul trap" idea apart structurally rather than accepting it at face value. Underneath it all is an invitation to think in structure rather than narrative, and to keep asking better questions.

Topics covered
afterlifenear-death experiencesreincarnationIan StevensonEben AlexanderRudolf Steinersoul trapconsciousnessConsciousness Transition Model
Share This Episode

Help Adrian and Brendan get this episode out there. Download an image for a feed post or a story, tag us (@brendandmurphyofficial) and share it with what you loved most about this conversation.

Or share the linkFacebookX
For The Love of Truth—Feed post share image
Feed post
1080 × 1350

Press and hold the image above to save it

For The Love of Truth—Story share image
Story
1080 × 1920

Press and hold the image above to save it

Transcript

[0:00] Introduction and what drew Brendan to consciousness research

Adrian: Brendan, thanks so much for coming on the show. It's a real pleasure to meet you.

Brendan: No, I appreciate it, Adrian. Good to be here.

Adrian: Fantastic. To help everyone that's going to watch this, could you tell me what your main areas of interest and research have been over the last twenty-three odd years?

Brendan: I like to be across a lot of different things, but the short answer to that question is that my main focus is consciousness and the nature of reality.

Adrian: Okay. What drew you to that subject in the first place?

Brendan: As a teenager, I was interested in a lot of the paranormal, the unexplained, that kind of world. I found it intriguing, and I liked watching the various TV shows about that kind of thing. So it was a casual interest. Then one day my brother came home from school. He was in year 11 at the time, and I had finished high school by then. He said, "This guy came in and gave a talk, and he kept talking about this book that I thought you might find interesting, so maybe you want to check it out." I made a mental note of that book and left it about six months, and then I went and looked it up. When I read it, it just blew my mind. It was like a high dose of DMT or something. It opened me up, and it lit that fire of curiosity that has never gone out since. Not long after that, I had my first mystical or peak experience, or whatever you want to call it.

It was quite a high-level experience, which I think solidified the path I was on at that point and locked me into it. I spent many years, and maybe I'm still doing it now, trying to make sense of that experience and what it meant about being alive and here and existing. So that was the beginning of the journey, I guess. I was... I had just turned...

[2:16] An engineer's mentality, not a guru's

Adrian: From the material you sent across and other things I've looked at online about you, it strikes me that you're not some kind of spiritual guru. You're much more interested in research and thinking things through, looking at where's the proof, what's behind this, what's actually going on, where's the correlation. Is that accurate?

Brendan: Yeah, exactly. I don't have a devotional temperament at all. I should say, not in regards to spirituality. I'm not a religiously minded person. I have that inquiring, researching mentality. I want to get underneath the hood, look at the mechanics, the rules, the processes and dynamics that other people are missing, and try to make sense of things from there. It's more like an engineer's mentality, I guess.

Adrian: Absolutely. I think that's a really good approach. It's certainly served me very well. It's a blessing and a curse being able to fix most things. [laughter] Especially when other people find out you can. But it's also extremely useful, because I tend to sit with things for a long time and really try to pick them apart and see what the mechanism is, what the process is, what's actually going on.

[3:02] The first book and the second

Adrian: You wrote your first book about fourteen years ago now?

Brendan: Yeah, the end of 2012.

Adrian: And what was the main focus of that?

Brendan: That was very much the investigation of the nature of reality. A lot of it was one foot in this world, one foot in the next world, studying it from as many different angles as I could. I'd already had that grounding in that peak experience in the depths of infinity, so I asked how I could present this to people from as many different angles as possible, showing that ultimately it all leads in the same direction. I was looking at all sorts of things: parapsychology research, remote viewing research, the mystical traditions, on and on and on. Very multidisciplinary. The thrust of it was that I'm trying to show people the fundamentals of who and what we are. That reframes the bigger picture of what we're doing here, what it means to exist, that kind of thing.

From there, what I'm doing now is finishing the second book, which has a much more restricted focus on the afterlife. Again I take a very cross-traditional, multidisciplinary approach and ask how the afterlife works, what it looks like when we get behind the stories and the experiences to the underlying mechanics of things. That's been my focus. I'm wrapping that up now, and I'm hoping to have it in people's hands in the first quarter of 2027.

Adrian: Fantastic. Going back to the first book, when you talk about the nature of reality, could you talk in broad terms about what your observations have been, how that altered things for you, and what you'd say to people about it?

Brendan: It's challenging for me, because I started from the perspective of a mystic. Aside from reading the book that set me on that path, I wasn't a skeptic trying to overcome skepticism, and I wasn't somebody recovering from religion. I just had my mind blown open, and then I had an experience of infinity. From there it was a question of how I could talk about this in different ways and make sense of it. So my path has been consistent. I haven't had to change my mind about a lot of things. It's been more about building out the picture and filling in the details. I don't know if I'm even answering your question. It's not that easy a question for me. It's a very broad, open one.

[6:04] What happens when we die: patterns across near-death experiences

Adrian: No, it is. What I'd like to spend some time talking about, because I've talked to other people about near-death experiences, is your take on what happens when we die. I think the best way to look at that is from the people who did die but are still here, because that gives you a much more accurate view. You've studied this far more than I have, and you're getting the same kind of information back from all sorts of people in all sorts of areas, aren't you?

Brendan: It's a very deep question. When people ask what the NDE thing is all about, it's actually very involved. When we look at all the different experiences people are having, you get different pieces of the puzzle. One person gives you a little puzzle piece, and another person gives you a different part. Then you have to try to make sense of it, because a lot of it is contradictory. They don't all fit together on the surface. At the level of perception it doesn't always fit together. But there are patterns and consistencies that are there structurally and have been for millennia. There are underlying processes that are more or less invariant, but the way the process gets dressed up aesthetically changes based on somebody's cultural experience and cultural conditioning.

You have the separation from the body, the out-of-body phase of the NDE, which is very common. You have perception of the body, perhaps from a nearby perspective. Then it can develop in different ways, and the figures that show up, beings, say divine figures, gods, deities, beings who are doing judgment maybe, all look different based on the culture the person comes from and their knowledge and experience. The thing I keep pointing out to people along the way is that it's not a cut-and-dried, simple discussion. When the body stops working, the only thing left is the mind, and the mind, without access to its normal physical orientation point and perspective, has to stabilize itself and essentially render its own environment for experience.

In doing so it draws on its own stored memories and ideas it's been exposed to in the past. It's a way of attempting to continue having some kind of continuity of experience, something coherent. So you end up with somebody who thinks, "Maybe I'm an atheist, but I've heard of Christianity, I've heard of Jesus." That's all they've got to work with, so now they're rendering their external environment in terms of those aesthetics, those figures and beings and ideas. It can be quite idiosyncratic in the initial stages of an NDE because of that, and it's not until you get past the interface phenomena that you get deeper into it. Just as a way of illustrating the point, if you get into the past-life regression material, those cultural overlays are largely gone. You get an invariant picture of what the afterlife looks like from all sorts of people all around the world, all different cultures, and they describe essentially the same thing. But you have to get to those deeper layers before you can find those invariant features.

Adrian: Right. That almost sounds like the first bit you talked about is more of a transit lounge, if you will.

[9:51] Does the brain produce consciousness or filter it?

Brendan: That's a great way of putting it. Consciousness is very creative in what the transit lounge ends up looking like.

Adrian: That makes a lot of sense to me. We talked briefly before we started recording about this. I was saying that we're largely blind, we only pick up something like 0.03% of the light spectrum, and we're largely deaf as well, because we only hear a tiny piece of the vibrational spectrum. You mentioned that the brain doesn't produce consciousness, it acts as a filter. Could you talk more about that?

Brendan: From where I stand, consciousness is obviously not produced by biology. When you get to swim in infinity, as I'm sure you've had various experiences of, it becomes obvious that biology doesn't create consciousness. It's the other way around. We perceive very little of so-called reality. The brain system, the body system, is acting as a constraint on consciousness rather than producing it. It actually reduces the awareness spectrum. It reduces the available information, the available consciousness bandwidth you would otherwise have, and this is embodied in near-death experiences and OBEs. When people's bodies stop working and they function without it, suddenly they have access to massive amounts of information. They feel like they become all knowledge. The constraint of biology gets lifted, and suddenly your perspective is infinitely expanded.

Adrian: That makes sense. I can't work out in my own mind whether it's a filtering device or whether we're here as a kind of focusing device, so that we have this very narrow band of focus where we can go really deep into something, but then you ignore everything around you.

Brendan: Right. It's an imposed bandwidth constraint that results from biology. I see it as both. It's a filter, or it's this other thing, and I think it's both at once, because when you tether consciousness to the human bio suit and the perceptual apparatus, the range of experience by default gets massively reduced. You end up in that massively focalized, narrow range of experience where I'm just Brendan, I'm just Adrian, this is me, I've got this body, I can only see 0.3% of the visual spectrum, and all this sort of stuff. That's the role of biology. I think it's really valuable. If you start with infinite consciousness, what else is there to experience? If you create different sorts of variables, and maybe invent the idea of the human being and planet Earth, and you can inject yourself into that like you're playing a video game and become the character in the game, you can have a very different experience. It's something the wider consciousness seems to find very valuable.

Adrian: That's absolutely right. I was going to say the word avatar, but that brings a film in and distorts what I wanted to say. I think I'll stick with an Adrian suit. It's the one I wear. [laughter]

Brendan: I like that. I like that. I'm going to use Brendan's suit [?] from now on.

Adrian: Yeah. And every once in a while the Adrian suit does some things you don't expect. [laughter] It doesn't always cooperate with what I intentionally wanted to do, but usually it ends up serving me. It's a cool way of putting it, I found anyway.

Brendan: Mm. It has its purpose.

[13:40] Eben Alexander's near-death experience

Adrian: So could you talk a little more about near-death experiences? Maybe some outstanding ones, where you think that really hammers home the point you were trying to make in the book.

Brendan: It's hard to pick them off the top of my head.

Adrian: Or broad categories, if that's easier.

Brendan: One of the most outstanding, and the more I've dug into it, the more profound it's gotten, was the NDE of Eben Alexander in 2008. His was amazing for probably more reasons than we can get into here, because the details really matter. In my manuscript I've given it quite a bit of time, to break it down and show that this correlates with this other thing. Long story short, he was a hardcore materialist, atheist character, and he had a meningitis situation kick off in his cortex and became comatose for a week. While he was in hospital comatose, he had this profound, really drawn-out NDE where he was able to traverse different levels or layers of the consciousness architecture. He would go from the physical level into the astral, the kama-lokic desire realm, then into the Devachan heavenly realm, and then into the depths of something you could call Source, something like a full void. Then he would come back, and then go back into the depths again, so he would cycle in and out, in and out, because he had a week to practise the routine. He actually described it as practice, I think.

One of the interesting aspects was that in the early stage, in the passage through the lower level [?] into this beautiful summerland, an outdoorsy, natural kind of realm, he encounters a girl. He's flying above this bucolic, beautiful village scene. He sees people outside, children laughing and playing, dogs running around, a really idyllic scene. He has this companion, this psychopomp, a girl who shows up and reassures him and says, "Don't worry, you're loved, you can never do anything wrong." She guides him through the stages all the way up to the point where he is on the verge of the Source. As she goes up into the next level, from the astral summerland into the heavenly Devachan realm, she turns into an orb of light, so she is accompanying him up and down this spectrum of consciousness.

Fast forward to the end, when he's recovered and his brain's back online. He learns through his biological family, because he was adopted, if memory serves me correctly, and they send him a photo. He realizes this is a photo of a sister he'd never met, who died before he was born.

Adrian: Wow.

Brendan: As he looks at it, he realizes that the girl in his NDE who turned into the orb was his sister, whom he had never met. For him it was a very profound confirmation that it was a real experience.

[16:48] Rudolf Steiner and the Devachan parallels

Brendan: What I've done is look at the structure of his experience and compare it to something I discovered not that long ago, which was a report from Rudolf Steiner. I'm sure you know Steiner. For those who don't, he was an Austrian seer, a metaphysician. He was initiated into the Rosicrucians. He was so connected and plugged in. He was fully clairvoyant. He was a philosopher, the creator of biodynamics, the creator of Waldorf education, on and on it goes. He was this polymath genius and clairvoyant, and he would explore the afterlife realms and report back on them and tell people, "This is what I'm seeing, this is what I've experienced."

His reports, particularly regarding the Devachan portion of Eben Alexander's experience, and that's not a term Alexander uses, I'm using it because Steiner and others have used it, line up with what Alexander found. When he gets to this realm after he leaves the astral summerland, it's a very heavenly, transcendent environment, a little more abstract and fluid, very beautiful. He looks up in the sky, far above him, and sees these winged beings flying around, and they're so full of joy that the joy comes coursing out of them. They emit sound into the environment around them, a beautiful, melodious sound, which is basically the sound of their unbridled joy coming out into the environment. So the dynamic is that they're emitting sensation out into the environment. They're not absorbing it. He's looking at them in awe, and he reaches for some kind of label or classification. He reaches for "angels," but that's not quite right. It's not quite enough.

If you look at what Rudolf Steiner describes of Devachan, he's describing the exact same kind of realm. He describes an air environment. It's not literal air, but that's the closest analogy, the flying, air realm. The beings in this realm that he saw, Steiner saw as well, and they're doing the same thing. They're emitting sensation into the environment, they're emitting sound into the environment. This Devachan realm is a sound-based, sonic environment. What Steiner describes is basically what Eben Alexander describes a century later from having an NDE while his brain is offline, his neocortex ravaged by meningitis. They're describing the very same dynamics and even the same beings. Steiner said these beings are not angels, they are archangels, and even by Steiner's time he was saying we'd lost the significance of the term. We didn't know what it really meant anymore. So these beings inhabit this realm that Eben Alexander got to experience 104 years later in his NDE while his brain was offline. That's just the beginning of the parallels and the things I've uncovered through excavating that.

[19:49] The Consciousness Transition Model

Adrian: That's really interesting. I believe you developed a Consciousness Transition Model. Could you talk about what that is and how it serves the information you've pulled together?

Brendan: The idea of this model is that consciousness is the fundamental, the ground of reality, and the only thing that's happening with consciousness, and the only thing that is real from where I stand, is consciousness going through transitions in its state of being or its mode of operation. So what I do is frame the afterlife in terms of that. It's an ongoing cycle of shifts in the state of consciousness, hence consciousness transition. I'm mapping that structurally, and mapping out the different layers, the different states of consciousness according to different traditions and what they call them. So, in a nutshell.

Adrian: That resonates with me as well, because I build maps of everything. I met Tony Buzan in '94, I think it was, and he does mind maps. Since then I've built, I don't know, hundreds of thousands of them. I do them all the time because it helps me make sense of things. I can see relationships and organizational concepts that in normal lists and normal right angles I just can't put together.

Brendan: Right, exactly.

Adrian: The deep questions I'm asking you are coming off a mind map now. I'm reading it on the next screen.

Brendan: Okay. [laughter] Nice. I like that you're prepared.

[21:21] Being misunderstood: structure versus narrative

Adrian: Well, I wouldn't like to waste your time. So I'm curious. I suspect you are misunderstood by some people. Is there a most misunderstood part of this for you, or is it just general?

Brendan: I'm used to being misunderstood at this point. It seems to be my day job. [laughter] Because I'm not coming from an established framework, I'm not sharing something that already exists out there. What I'm talking about is something that is only in this book, so people haven't had the opportunity to access it and read it and see it yet. Most podcast hosts have a really difficult time with me because they don't know where I'm operating from and they don't know what to ask me. It is challenging. Even a lot of people who are relatively awake on the spectrum default to ideas that already exist out there in the world, a lot of which are, quite frankly, not correct. I know that's shocking to you, Adrian, but bear with me. [laughter]

They have to try to interpret what I'm saying through their existing schema, which is full of ideas that need to be updated. I'm coming from a structural place where most people are operating from narrative: I had an experience, therefore that's how reality works, or this guy had this experience, therefore that's how reality works. They're operating at the level of perception equals ontology. I'm not operating from that. I'm saying, what if we look at perception and pull it apart and excavate and find out what's underneath, what is actually happening? That's not something most people are accustomed to doing. They're not used to thinking structurally. They're used to thinking narratively and in terms of belief, and what do I feel good about, what do I feel comfortable with. "I'll just roll with that. That's what reality is to me. It is what makes me feel comfortable." So I'm triggering to a lot of different people, even the relatively awake ones, because I'm pulling apart everything. [laughter]

[23:40] Asking better questions and being infinitely ignorant

Adrian: That's great, and it's one of the reasons I wanted to speak to you as well, because hopefully more and more people are beginning to realize that most of everything they've ever been taught has been taught for an agenda, not because it's right or truthful. If they learn to ask better quality questions, they'll start to get to the bottom of things, which is why I say to people, "Look, I actually don't care what you think. I really don't. I just care that you are thinking for yourself." And if you learn to ask better questions, you will start to reveal the nature of things. [section omitted] I said, "If we now assume everything's wrong, everything I've ever been taught, I need to relearn from the ground up." Even though I was already a long way down that path, that fundamental shift in my thought process really changed how I view everything now. It also made me realize that as much as I think I know a lot, I actually know pretty much nothing about anything, [laughter] which is a good place to come from, because I am curious and I keep going.

Brendan: Exactly. I like to say that we're all infinitely ignorant.

Adrian: Yes.

Brendan: That's not ever going to change. Even if I read another five thousand books, I'll still be infinitely ignorant. I'll just be slightly less infinitely ignorant. Ultimately, we're swimming in a sea of information and data that we can never fully apprehend. Even just the stuff that's produced in one or two or three fields of human endeavour on a daily or weekly basis exceeds my ability or your ability to digest it all, let alone the entire field of human endeavour. What's available out there in terms of knowledge and perspective and information is always increasing exponentially beyond what we're capable of keeping up with. That's just the earthly perspective, never mind the cosmic level of it. Forget about it. So as embodied humans, we're infinitely ignorant. It's a good way to stay humble. I think I have some good perspectives and good answers, but it doesn't mean I think I have all the answers, and I never will. If you get to that place where you say, "I've got my favourite holy book, therefore I have all the answers," you're suffering a form of mental illness. It's delusional to think you've got it all. It's just never going to happen. It sustains the mentality of inquiry, I think.

Adrian: Mhm. That's a really important one. So everyone, keep asking questions, for God's sake and for your own sake.

[26:42] Ian Stevenson's reincarnation research

Adrian: It was interesting, I saw it mentioned in your work and I've been looking into it as well, Ian Stevenson's work on reincarnation. Could you dive into that a little bit and give some stories and examples of why that work is relevant?

Brendan: It's really interesting why it's relevant. In simple terms, he produced a lot of evidence for reincarnation in a linear sense, one life followed by another life. He did the most comprehensive research, unbelievable research. He did this for forty years, and in an average year he traveled something like 55,000 miles, going to remote places to interview mostly children who had memories of another life. He would interview the child and get their perspective, and then go and interview the family the child remembered being a part of in the other life. He treated it like the Sherlock Holmes of reincarnation. He was a very methodical, rigorous investigator, and he tried essentially to disprove the reincarnation hypothesis. When he'd stripped away all the other possibilities and that was the only thing left, it was like, "Well, here it is, what are you going to do?" Here's a child who remembers these details that are correct, we've shown they're correct, from this other lifetime, this other family who lives a hundred miles away, and we don't have any other way of explaining it. If you're desperate, you could maybe resort to the super-psi hypothesis, where they say it's a psychic ability and they're not really reincarnated, but even then a lot of it doesn't hold up.

There was a young girl, Swarnlata Mishra, I think it was, and I mention her in the book because she was one of his most striking cases. She not only remembered this other family she'd been a part of, but had a very deep, felt emotional attachment and connection to that other family. She still acknowledged her biological family in this life, but she had essentially the full memory and personality of the other one in this new body. She was living almost a double life. The information she provided was accurate about what the building used to look like, the house. She'd say, "There was a tree here that's no longer there. Where's it gone? There was a veranda here. Where's that gone? You've changed that." So these were details she was remembering, and the super-psi hypothesis doesn't really tally up, because her memories of how things were in the other life stopped at the moment that other personality died.

Adrian: Mm.

Brendan: Her memories and the information she had were not up to date. It was like a freeze frame from when that other person had died. She also remembered a lifetime in between those two lives, a very short lifespan. I think she said this other character had died at about the age of nine or something like that, and she had access to some of those memories as well. She knew songs from that lifetime that she had not learned in the current lifetime, and again they were accurate. There was no other plausible way of explaining it. He had a lot of cases like that, and things like birthmarks that correlated with the other personalities, how they died, what killed them. If it was a gunshot wound, there was a birthmark here and often a birthmark at the exit point of where the bullet would have hit them. You're really stretching the alternative explanations when you're trying to get away from reincarnation. He had a lot of stuff like that. He did the most comprehensive work of anybody.

[30:29] The limits of language

Adrian: It all ties together with what you said, that consciousness exists and we're focusing into it or filtering it, whatever we're doing, but there's something much grander going on than the majority of people are aware of.

Brendan: Absolutely. I think it's maybe beyond our full comprehension. I wonder to what extent it's possible to apprehend it at all, even outside of the body. It just seems like the scope is infinite and maybe even continually expanding. When somebody dies, the options available are huge. We're really swimming in a huge mystery.

Adrian: We are. I think one of the other challenges with all of this stuff, and I've felt this about so many things, is that language, any language, and probably particularly English since that's the one I understand most, is limiting when you're trying to describe a concept that there's no real word framework to drop it into. I feel like I flounder around sometimes trying to get the point. I could probably draw it better, but as far as finding the words for it, no.

Brendan: There are so many times I've been talking to someone and thought, "If I could just draw you a diagram, that would really help." It's not that it's literally how things are, but if you can map it out visually for people, it helps certain things land. When I talk about a tiered structure of consciousness, a taxonomy of consciousness states, to a lot of people that doesn't mean anything, but if they can see it, it's like, "Oh, okay. So we've got the physical band here, we've got the astral here, we've got the mental here, we've got the higher, more abstract states up here, and then at the very top of the so-called pyramid of experience we've got this tiny point of the Atma, which is so abstract that we really can't apprehend it with words at all." I've tried, and it's really messy. The more you try to elaborate on it, the worse it gets. [laughter] So it's a real problem. Our concepts and language are relevant within the spectrum of consciousness states up to a certain point. Even when they talk about these mid-tier heaven realms, they're very difficult to describe, let alone the more abstract ones that bear no resemblance to earth-life experience.

This is where you have people inventing terminology to try to capture the abstractness of it. Helena Blavatsky, at the level of the Atma, was talking about being, but instead of "being" or "beingness" she used "be-ness," B-E-N-E-S-S, because it sounds more abstract and is therefore a slightly better way of putting it. Rudolf Steiner, who was a colleague of hers in the early days, was talking about the Atma being a product of the Hindu or Indic mind, and that there was no European equivalent. The European mind just wasn't even equipped to come up with a term for that level of experience. It just couldn't do it. So it's really challenging.

Adrian: That makes sense. On the odd occasions where I have to send things into a court with an affidavit, as an example, to make sure there's no doubt, I end up sending my own dictionary of words in there, to make sure they understand what my words mean in the context I want them to accept and understand them.

Brendan: Right, exactly.

Adrian: We have this all the time when we speak to people, where you think, "The message transmitted was definitely not what I think you just received from me." [laughter]

Brendan: Yep, yep.

[34:18] The soul trap

Adrian: So let's start again. Could you talk a little about the soul trap, which seems to be gaining popularity with people? The idea that we're trapped. I don't see that and I don't buy it, but I'd love your take on that.

Brendan: Again, it's one of these things where people are persuaded by powerful experiences. At the level of perception, perception is real in itself, if that makes sense. The experience is real, but the interpretation we put on it, the story we tell about the experience, is consistently not right, because people don't understand certain things about altered states, or what happens to perception or the psyche when it is no longer tethered to the physical body. Interestingly, even when it is still tethered, that's where we get some of the most bizarre and unhelpful material, in altered states where somebody's nervous system is very much awake and alive. That is a huge contributor to this phenomenon that I call the astral fantasia. It's a low-level state of the collective. You can think of it as a bubble around humanity, a low-level conceptual arena, but it's a holographic environment, a virtual reality, that you can alter your state of consciousness to get into and experience. It's unbelievably real, unbelievably convincing and hypnotic, and people have these forays into it and encounter beings that they may interpret as aliens, or devils, or Archons, these handler-type things administering the psaltery [?].

There are a lot of problems with that esoterically. For example, we've had multiple traditions going back over the last couple of centuries that have warned us how illusory and unreliable perception in the astral planes can be, all the more so if you go in there unprepared. I would suggest that very, very few people on the face of the earth go in adequately prepared. You need to have a certain awareness and knowledge, and most of the people, even the ones who are talented and good at going in there and having astral, out-of-body type experiences, go in with that skill but not with the knowledge base and the perspective to interpret the experiences that follow. So it's a real problem. We've had all sorts of people, Eliphas Levi, Rudolf Steiner, Blavatsky, the Rosicrucians, Sri Aurobindo, warning us how illusory and unreliable perception is in those states. If you're a Vedantin, you'd say it's all illusion, the only thing that's real is the highest pinnacle of consciousness, the Atman, the Brahman, and that's it. But I don't want to dismiss and reduce the experiences people are having. I'm trying to work with it as if it's relatively real or contingently real, but let's not take it at surface level. Let's not say, "This is what it looks like, therefore that's how reality works." That's the first mistake, taking things at face value.

In those realms, people get disconnected from bodily awareness, and the psyche then renders its environment. It has to manufacture its own environment. This all happens automatically and unconsciously, and nobody talks about it. Carl Jung talked about this in some detail, and he died over sixty years ago, so we've known about this in depth psychology, clinical psychology, for a long time. There are aspects of the psyche that externalize themselves, and they appear as people or beings of some sort. Over time, if you look at the chronology a little bit, you see the beings showing up becoming increasingly varied, increasingly bizarre and increasingly alien. Before 1900, you would really struggle to find an example of an alien in any of these visionary experiences. Now, in 2026, we have over a hundred species being reported. So there's a problem there. [laughter] People need to understand that the psyche manifests itself as beings. Jung talked about affects and complexes in the psyche showing up as a person. They look like a person or an entity and they behave as one. It's critical to understand, particularly in the soul trap context, that the parts of the psyche that show up external to you behave as if they are their own being. They seem completely autonomous. They seem to have their own thoughts, their own opinions. They want to persuade you to do certain things: get back in your body, you're not finished yet, you've got more work to do, all this kind of stuff.

On the surface level, the soul trap crowd like this stuff, because on the surface it seems to support the idea that there's manipulation and control and what have you. But they're missing so many pieces of the puzzle to interpret the phenomena. Even the case studies I've seen supplied, if you look at them thoroughly, with an engineer's mentality, you can see that they fall apart. It's funny, because they use it as support for something when it's actually proving the opposite. It's a weird situation. A lot of people are quite happy with the soul trap mythology that's been built up. One thing that doesn't get pointed out is that we don't look at the ancient mythologies of cultures past and take them literally. Generally, educated people don't go, "Those gods or beings or heroes were real and this is how reality works." But that's what we're doing with this modern soul trap astral mythology. We're taking it literally and saying this is how it really works, with no awareness of the way the psyche operates when it's disembodied and trying to orient itself.

There are some really classic examples out there. Isabella Green, in her book Leaving the Trap [?], gives a case study of her friend who had an NDE. He pops out of his body and he's confronted by these beings, which of course most people assume are independent, autonomous external beings. He has this back-and-forth conversation with them, and they're trying to encourage him to get back in his body and finish out his life. He doesn't want a bar of it, and he leaves the scene. So they had no power over him, no control over him, even though people use that as an example of power and control and manipulation. Very strange. So he leaves, and he continues his NDE. He hears a voice tell him something along the lines of "find the true light." I've got the exact words in my book. He finds himself in a corridor lined with doors, kind of like a scene from the second Matrix film, that narrow, brightly lit corridor. There's light shining out from behind the doors, like under the cracks. He picks a door, walks through it, and finds himself tumbling back into his body anyway.

He hasn't won a victory over the Archons or the soul trap. He's back in his body because his body wasn't dead yet. That's why he ends up there. The interaction he had with these beings that he interpreted as separate, Archontic figures, didn't matter. It didn't matter what he did there or what he said to them. He could have said, "Okay, yep, I'll hop back in my body." Whether he refused or not, ultimately his body wasn't dead and his journey wasn't over, so he wakes up back in his body anyway, even though he didn't want to, even though he won the argument with the Archons. It's weird how people get hypnotically focused on "Oh, he left the Archon conversation, he ignored them, he won, he defied them, therefore there is a soul trap, and he's somehow winning a battle." It doesn't make sense structurally. Logically, it doesn't add up.

So this is the thing, and I see, Adrian, you appreciate the engineer's mentality here: let's pull it apart and look at the mechanics underneath. The psyche manufactures figures spontaneously, automatically, unconsciously. Your belief systems, your affect, your emotional system show up as beings. It might show up as a group of beings, or as one. It might show up as a being of light, or as an alien, or as God knows what. The possibilities are extensive. But we're overlooking all these things and taking the surface level of it, and throwing all these concepts and entities into the same mythological bucket. It doesn't matter if it's coherent, it doesn't matter if it adds up, let's just believe this new story. It's a really hypnotic, entertaining story. It's become this interstellar cosmological soap opera of massive proportions. You've got alien factions battling each other. You've got the Buddha piloting a jet plane shooting at the aliens. I've literally seen a remote viewer report that. It just gets more and more absurd and bizarre. If the Buddha existed historically, the last place you're going to find him is piloting a Star Wars-style jet fighter shooting aliens. It's so insane what's been developing mythologically, but it's really captivating and entertaining, and it seems real for the people in that holographic immersive environment, because perceptually it's real. So we just need to disengage, take a step back and ask, what's underneath this perception? What is driving this story that just keeps getting more involved and complicated and bizarre? Anyway, that was a good little rant.

Adrian: No, that's good. I think if people would pay attention to the most common logical fallacies and apply them to the thinking process about these things as well, that would start to poke some holes in it for them and reveal the nature of things more accurately.

[44:14] What Brendan hopes people take away

Brendan: Right. Basic logic. It's not as popular to have to think your way through things and examine things carefully. It's much more popular to just adopt a cool story.

Adrian: I agree. What would you hope people would take from this very pleasant conversation we've had? [laughter] Because I've really enjoyed it.

Brendan: Likewise. The reason I talk to people on podcasts is largely because I want to point people back to the writing and the work in the books, because ultimately there's a level of context and perspective that somebody has to have in order to, for example, tackle the soul trap conversation. What I'm doing is trying to equip people structurally, logically, conceptually, so that they can interpret whatever they come across, whether it's a soul trap report, an NDE, an altered state on LSD, whatever it might be, and have a phenomenological map, so they can say, "Ah, this makes sense now that I can see it like this."

I've had these conversations with people. Recently we were visited by our beloved nanny, Susie, a Mexican woman who lives in one of the neighbouring states. She came to visit, and she had a conversation with me, which I recorded, to tell me all about her NDE that she had many years ago. It was fascinating. I was able to show her that what she was talking about exists in other traditions, and they have names and labels for it, this and this and this, and build a bit of context for her around that. She was asking, "What is this experience? It makes no sense to me," because it wasn't one of the usual astral plane type experiences, where I met beings, I met my family. It wasn't anything like that. It was very abstract: infinite consciousness, infinite thoughts happening all at once. She's perceiving all this information, and she was asking, "What good is that experience to me? What does that mean? How does it apply to anything?" So I tried to provide her with some context. By the end of that conversation I saw something really land for her. She sat there and got kind of misty-eyed, and I thought, "Ah, good, it's starting to land. Great." So this is what perspective can do for people. I hope it doesn't sound conceited. I just know what's out there, and I know that what I've put together is different. So I want people to give it the time. If people still believe in that arcane practice of reading, then by any means necessary, get your hands on this work.

[47:19] Book Two and building a framework

Adrian: I saw you've mentioned that you think this will be a trilogy. Your first book was fourteen years ago. Could the second book be read without the context of the first book, or would that add more depth and flavour, so the second book would make more sense, do you think?

Brendan: I've deliberately set the second book up so it stands on its own.

Adrian: Cool, brilliant.

Brendan: I didn't want to put people through "you've got to go read this 600-page beast before you can come here." [laughter]

Adrian: I've just been through the entire Dune series plus all the follow-up books by his son. I did them in the end by audiobook, because I thought that suited me better, but you sit down to the book and you're like, "Jesus Christ, twenty-four hours to listen to, and that's just one."

Brendan: Oh, wait till you read Plotinus. It's a hundred hours of reading time. [laughter]

Adrian: Holy God.

Brendan: It's just wild. So I'm doing the tedious, boring work so that other people don't have to.

Adrian: That's a really good thing, and I think it's really important. One thing I learned a long time ago about any kind of knowledge is that if you can build a framework first before you start to pour the knowledge into it, that's really helpful. Otherwise you can end up with a wonky, weird skyscraper-type thing that will fall over because there's no solid foundation for it to build on.

Brendan: Exactly, and that's what I'm finding is the issue with a lot of our belief systems of different types. They're not built on a strong foundation, and as soon as a strong wind blows, they come tumbling down. So I want to give people a chance to see or hold something a lot more robust that will withstand being stress tested.

[48:49] Closing thoughts and where to find the book

Adrian: That's fantastic. Can you think of anything you'd like to add that we haven't covered in this discussion?

Brendan: Oh, man.

Adrian: We could be here for days with that question, I suppose. [laughter]

Brendan: We'd be here for a very long time. One of the things I never really get to talk about is that what I've tried to do is take hundreds of different perspectives, frameworks, disciplines, fields of research and esoteric traditions and bring them together and show the structural connection points, where they support each other, and how that liberates you from the need to have the belief system of this group or that group. You can stand in the openness of the possibilities that emerge from that coherence rather than being polarized into "this is my religion and those opinions are all wrong," because I'm trying to defend this tiny little perspective. One of the things I found really useful along the way, Adrian, surprisingly useful, is using computing and internet technologies and communications analogies to describe how the consciousness architecture works. At times the similarities between them are really shocking, and that's not something I see out there in general. I've injected it into the book, so there's that extra layer of "here's another way of looking at this." This is not someone with a belief system. This is someone looking for a structural, mechanical, engineering understanding of what's going on. I know that's a point of differentiation between this and the other works I'm seeing, because I've seen a lot. I've slaved over this for so long to make it something different and unusual, and I know that if people access it, their minds will never be the same.

Adrian: Fantastic. So where can people find you, and can they pre-order the book, that kind of thing?

Brendan: They can absolutely pre-order it. We're taking pre-orders at brendandmurphy.com. I'll send you the link if I haven't already.

Adrian: I've already got it. Thank you. I'll put it in the show notes.

Brendan: Awesome. That's the place to go to access it and get your hands on it. The pre-order situation is different because we're offering a little bit that won't be available once pre-orders are complete, so there are a few different options for people. We're also going to kick off a book club early in December, I think December 3rd, so people have the chance to get hands on books but also get access to the book club at the same time. We're doing a book club for Book One and a separate one for Book Two afterwards. We're going to have weekly... oh, sorry, once a month, live calls, and we're going to work...

Adrian: I was going to say you're going to be a busy guy with weekly. [laughter]

Brendan: No, definitely not weekly, just monthly. That's enough. So at the moment those options are there for people if they want to get a high level of access, and some extra little things.

Adrian: Fantastic. Brendan, that was awesome. I'm going to end that now, but don't go away, because I want to talk to you for a minute.

Brendan: Sounds good. Thanks, mate.

Adrian: Perfect. Thanks, buddy.

Explore further